Talk:McAnally/@comment-71.175.7.210-20160205035040/@comment-216.49.155.79-20190724201841

These are both reasonable guesses, although I think the latter is more likely (Mac's dark is so heavily emphasized, including his "new dark") - the former I'm betting is trapped inside the prison itself (Skin Game). There's also the possibility he's either Darby or Danforth from "At the Mountains of Madness" (or both), given the "distant and inaccessible as antarctic mountains" line in Cold Days. Or the Miskatonic character and Gambrinus are the same entity under different histories/mantles.